I started
talking about this coming winter even before the summer. I've directly and indirectly said I believe
this winter will be quite cold and chilly. I said months ago that this winter
most likely would be coming early and staying late. The success I had
forecasting during this year's Atlantic hurricane season is the same pattern
going forward. The Pacific and Atlantic tropical seasons will have an impact on
winter 2018-2019. I've been trying to keep all y'all informed; I started
posting my preliminary thoughts on this
winter back on August 7th. But even way before that I've posted about the
evolving pattern and how that pattern related to this upcoming winter. If you
haven't read my preliminary winter thoughts, I encourage you to do so. Here are
the links.
Those three
part installments laid the ground work for this post. We are now in the last part of October. So
far everything I've been talking about
on my weather pages and in several blog post has come to past. we are now quickly changing over the winter
pattern; the cold has indeed arrived early.
Before I get started, first of all let me say for the umpteenth time , I
think it will be a cold and snowy winter for much of the eastern half of the
U.S.
But
remember I'm talking overall colder than
average temperatures and above average snowfall for most of the Northeast and
the Mid Atlantic. It won't be subzero all the time; as we see every winter
there will be warm ups from time to time. Also remember wintertime
precipitation is sleet, freezing rain,
snow, and sometimes even rain. The
pattern going forward will support all of these at some points over winter
2018-2019.
Last winter
we saw a lot of variable conditions. It
started out cold, then got very cold from around Christmas into the first week
of January. Mid January into much of
February we warmed to well above average. Then cooled back off for March into
Much of April. We also had five major
nor'easters. One In January and four back to back in March.
OK what about this winter:
The
Northeast and Middle-Atlantic have turned very cold by October standards. As we get
into November the trough will adjust west and sit over the Plains. Then it should adjust back east as we get into
winter.
The models
are moving toward the thoughts I've been laying out. Even the CFSv2 (which normally has a hard time finding cold
in any pattern) is coming around to the idea that the Northeast and
Mid-Atlantic will be quite cold this winter. The JMA and Euro are also adjusting to a very
cold look for December through February. The Euro weekly is showing a lot of cold for
2/3 of the CONUS over the next 46 days, the core of the cold looks to be over
the Great Lakes, Midwest, and the Northeast. This would absolutely play into the pattern
I've been talking about for months.
Here is how
the CFSv2 has been progressing.
The Euro 46
day overall temperature anomaly.
Analog
Years:
1958-1959 1968-1969, 1972-1973
1976-1977,1977-1978, 1986-1987, 1994-1995, 2002-2003, 2006-2007, 2009-2010,
2014-2015. 2002-03 is leading the pack at least for now. If you remember back to 2002-03 that October
acted very much like this one. Other years that are in the running are 1968-69,
1986-87, 1994-95, and 2009-10, 2014-2015. When
doing analogs we blend the years that had similar patterns; this is what the
temperature outlook maps are based on. The maps show an overall blend of those
analog years. So during the winter,
different aspects of those analog years will manifest themselves.
Looking at the Sea Surface
Temperature (SST) anomalies:
The Pacific:
The
El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO):
Winters tend to be colder than average in the Central
and Eastern US during El Nino Modoki, as opposed to an Eastern based normal El
NIno which tends to be warmer in the Central and Eastern U.S.
The
ENSO region in the Pacific is heading
toward a weak to moderate Modoki
(centrally based) El Nino in the tropical Pacific. The El Nino
conditions are becoming more and more apparent. Looking at the global SST pattern, the
tropical Pacific has a very distinct El Nino look. We can also see the colder SST near South
America. Over the next several weeks we will see the ENSO evolve toward a
Modoki even more. The subsurface water
temperatures already show the El Nino
Modoki footprint. The reason a Modoki leads to East Coast troughing has to do with how energy release forces a trough north of the center of the warm SST. If the heat is in the central Pacific then there will be a trough in the north central Pacific south of the Aleutians. This would cause a ridge east of the trough. This ridge would be over the West Coast. This in turn means a overall trough would be over the East Coast. If the warm SST were in the eastern Pacific, the process would cause a trough over the West Coast and a Ridge over the East Coast. We saw this occur back in 2015.
The
Eastern Pacific Oscillation:
When we have
a Modoki El Nino, it improves the odds for a negative EPO. A negative EPO would
allow the eastern Pacific to warm up, bringing some of this warmth to the west
coast of North America.
The
Blob:
Warmer than
normal water in the northern Pacific. The blob is looking quite extraordinary.
The last time it looked similar to this was the winter of 2014-2015. A strong
blob Is a good indication of West Coast Ridging setting up during winter
2018-2019.
The Quasi-Biennial Oscillation (QBO):
The QBO has
a direct correlation to winter weather patterns.
The QBO is
east based but is trending west. But I think we will see the east based QBO hang
around into February. This is important, when the QBO is in the eastern phase
we tend to see more stratospheric warming events, especially when combined with
low solar activity.
PDO:
The Pacific
Decadal Oscillation (PDO), like all teleconnections it has a warm and cool
phase. The PDO has a big impact on the strength of the ENSO. The PDO can
intensify or diminish the impacts of the ENSO. A warm phase PDO will work hand
in hand with an El Nino. A cold phase in the PDO will amplify the effects of La
Nina. Conversely, if the PDO and ENSO are in opposite phases they act as a
counter balance to each other. Last fall
we had a positive PDO that was trending negative. Winter 2017-2018 featured a neutral
trending to a negative PDO. The result was we had a trough in the west and a stronger than
average southeast ridge what causes all kinds of havoc with our winter
temperatures.
The PDO is positive (This is the so called
"warm blob" That sits just south of Alaska) and that looks to continue into at least
Spring of 2019. This would help promote the western ridge and an east trough.
This would help ensure below average
temperatures in the Southeast, Mid Atlantic into the Northeast. This would also
favor above average winter precipitation too.
The Atlantic:
We have
above average SST along the East Coast and Gulf of Mexico. Those warm SST will help to lend support to
any coastal storms that do develop. With
general eastern troughing expected, we should see chances for digging troughs to
amplify and phase with the cold arctic air.
So there will be a chance for at least a few bigger Nor'easters.
Colder than
average temperatures near Greenland. The
winter of 2014-2015 saw this area of the North Atlantic even colder than it is
now. Those on the global warming side of
the isle say this cold blob is because the current and circulation patterns in
the Atlantic are slowing. But I think it
is just because of climate variability.
The Atlantic
Oscillation (AO) and North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) have been strongly
positive for a long time. But Hurricane
Michael has forced a pattern change. Part of the change was warming in the
stratosphere. As a result of that the AO and NAO have both tanked. With the negative AO and NAO we now have
blocking setting up. The blocking is leading to all that cold Canadian air to
pour south into the U.S. This kind of
blocking pattern is exactly what one would expect from a east based QBO. Those cold SST around Greenland is a good
signal for a colder Northeast.
The
Indian Ocean:
The
east Indian Ocean is cooler than the
west Indian Ocean and northeast of Australia.
This is important, when we have
that setup in the Indian Ocean and a El Nino we tend to see the MJO try to stay
neutral or stay in the colder phases for the East Coast. Phases 8,1, and 2.
The Madden-Julian Oscillation (MJO):
The factors
above have an influence on the MJO. The
MJO will be what decides where the strongest convection will set up. This in turn will affect how the Pacific jet
behaves. Last winter the MJO moved into
warm phases 4,5, and 6. This caused the warmth we experienced for the end of
January and February. When we have a
Modoki El Nino the MJO is typically able to push farther eastward do to the
effect on air motion in the Central Pacific.
This leads to plenty of moisture for MJO caused convection. A Modoki El Nino sees warm SST in the central
Pacific with cooler SST east and west of there. Typically when we see colder
SST in Indonesia we tend to see the MJO stay mostly or completely in the colder
phases 8,1, and 2. This is another key showing we should have a colder winter.
Solar Cycle:
Low solar
activity is a sign for cooler as opposed to warmer winter temperatures. There is a weak correlation between solar
activity and temperature. The reason for
this is most likely because when the Sun is quiet we have last solar radiation
impacting the atmosphere. It has been noticed that when we have less solar
radiation impacting the Earth, we have increased ozone levels in the
Stratosphere. A warmer Stratosphere over the Arctic means the polar vortex is
weaker, which makes it easier for pieces of the cold arctic air can break off
and migrate south into the CONUS. It was Drew Shindell who first noticed the
connection between ozone level and temperature.
This season
we have a very quiet Sun. So this supports my thoughts on a colder than average
winter here in the Northeast.
Snowpack and High Latitude Blocking:
Northern
Hemisphere snowpack is valuable tool in trying to figure out if we will see
high latitude blocking during the upcoming winter. This can help us gauge if
the winter will be more inclined for cold shots. Siberian snow cover is behind from where it
was last year at this time. could this throw a monkey wrench into my
outlook...maybe. But on the other hand, the area where the snow is located is more
important than the extent of coverage.
When looking at Eurasia we're concerned if there is snow below 60⁰ N; There has
been expanding snow in that part of Siberia. So based on Eurasia snow cover, there is weak
signal for high latitude blocking. The Canadian and Greenland Snowpack are well
above average for this time of year. There has also been snow in the Rockies, this
is ahead of last year. Snowpack is a
very important factor; the more snow the more modification the air masses will
experience over the winter as they drop
south.
There is a
correlation between years that have low solar activity and blocking near
Greenland. All of this is a good
indicator that we should see above average chances for blocking this winter.
There is a
correlation between tropical activity and East Coast winter temperatures. Strong October Gulf Hurricanes tend to precede
cold East Coast winters. Another
interesting tidbit, is years that saw a Pacific tropical cyclone impact the
desert Southwest also lead to cold East Coast winters. This year we saw two do this.
The bottom line:
Summer into
Fall 2018 has been acting very El Nino Modoki like.
Temperature:
I have
strong confidence that I'm right on the developing pattern. All of the factors I went over work to
influence the Idea of an East Coast Trough, with the higher probability for
Greenland Blocking, I think this will be a fairly cold winter. Here is a look
at both my thoughts on winter temperatures across the CONUS and for the
Northeast and Middle-Atlantic.
We have to
expect the trough over the east right now, will relax and pull west for part of December, maybe even into the start of January. But any warmth for December/January shouldn't be a blowtorch. The warming could last two to four weeks. During this time, we would see more in the way of temperatures slightly above
average to above average. November will still most likely end up being overall below average. The cold that is available could overwhelm the pattern, making for some periods of near record to record breaking cold. December most likely will be warm. But the seasonal temperatures should come back around Christmas. The first week or two of January could be warmer than average. Then the bottom could fall out, with things becoming very cold. The analog years I've latched onto would support that Idea. But I think , the rest of January, February ,
and into March look pretty overall cold based on the analogs and the pattern
that has been with us all year. The
Models are trending colder, this is a good sign that I'm on the right track for
this upcoming December through February timeframe.
Winter Precipitation:
Winters that
feature an El Nino Modoki tend to see more of an active southern jet stream. An active southern branch increases the
likelihood of East Coast winter storms. ... more snow storms....more
snow. This is why I have the
Middle-Atlantic into the Southeast with well above average snowfall for this
winter. There is also the risk for a few
ice storms this winter. The Ice storm risk will be greatest in the Southeast;
but, I can't rule out the possibility of an ice storm in the Northeast. I'm thinking this winter will see slightly
below average to average lake effect snow in the snow belts . But lake snow is volatile
so trying to forecast the entire Lake Effect season is almost impossible. But based on the analogs, I think my Lake
effect idea has merit.
If something
happens that changes my mind on some of this; I will post an update on the
temperature and precipitation pattern for this winter around mid November.
Images
courtesy of WeatherBell Analytics, Tropical Tidbits, National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration, National Solar Observatory.
Hello Rebecca, I am the Executive Director of FOOT'S FORECAST in Central MD. I am in complete agreement with your analysis. In Central MD (which also includes South Central PA), we are expecting a wetter and iceier pattern for Jan - Mar as you had alluded to. We appreciate your dedication and hard work. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteKeith
You're welcome Keith. I do thank you for your support.
ReplyDeleteVery nicely done.. I would tend to agree though Im not sure some of the coastal sections of the mid Atlantic will fair dreadfully cold.. but definitely below average. Could be an epic winter for some !
ReplyDeleteThank you......... Because of the scope of the region....there is a risk some areas won't work out as expected. But Overall I think the analysis and outlook are sound.
DeleteHOw is it looking for cape cod Massachusetts for winter snow?
ReplyDeleteAs the maps shows above to well above average snowfall.
DeleteThank you for all your hard work. Now, based on what I just read, it is time to get all of the equipment ready for Winter. Just looking for one more long ride on the Harley before it goes to bed for the winter.
ReplyDeleteEnjoy......
DeleteWe should warm up again enough to bike ride for the Middle of November before the cold comes back for the end of November.